Breaking the Cycle: Why Tough Rhetoric Won't Solve Crime and Drug Issues

Simon McLean criticises how both major political parties employ tough-on-crime rhetoric without addressing underlying issues. He argues that "everything they suggest about getting tougher, more proactive and increasing enforcement simply feeds the fire" rather than tackling growing demand.

McLean contends there is no genuine drug problem — only failed drug policy and prohibition. He claims political leaders lack expertise on these matters yet continue making expensive enforcement decisions that inadvertently create black markets where criminals flourish.

The former undercover detective emphasises that tough talk and illogical rhetoric leave vulnerable families and communities devastated. He states that "when we try to arrest ourselves out of a situation," the result is predictable failure, particularly given insufficient police resources for basic street-level functions.

McLean advocates for nuanced approaches incorporating expertise and cross-continental cooperation rather than continued enforcement-focused strategies. He concludes that 53 years of failed drug policy should have taught politicians lessons they've apparently ignored, suggesting citizens bear responsibility for not holding officials accountable.

He notes that when bad laws create illicit markets — for tobacco, alcohol, or drugs — "the worst among us will exploit the opportunity afforded them by providing an illegal supply."